A Wild Time at Wildy Well Pat Garrett vs Oliver Lee & Jim Gililland

MAY12_CG_Garrett RanchJuly 12, 1898

A t around 4 a.m., Doña Ana County Sheriff Pat Garrett and his posse are trying to sneak up on murder suspects Oliver Lee and Jim Gililland at Lee’s Wildy Well Ranch, east of the Jarilla Mountains in New Mexico.

Lee and Gililland are wanted for the murder of Albert Jennings Fountain and his eight-year-old son Henry.

For Garrett, it’s almost 17 years to the day since the incident that made him famous (or infamous)—the killing of Billy the Kid. This is a chance for him to reclaim some of the glory that had eluded him since that night in Fort Sumner. He may be able to restart a law enforcement career that stalled more than a decade ago.

He’s headed for a disappointment.

The lawmen break into the adobe house, finding the Madison family asleep in their beds. Lee and Gililland are asleep on the adobe’s flat roof, protected by a two-foot-high wall.

Garrett and his men leave the house and reposition themselves, ready for a fight. He leads two of them onto the roof of the shed attached to the house. Another guards the Madisons, and one takes cover behind a nearby water tank. All are exposed to any gunfire from the suspects.

Garrett calls for Lee and Gililland to surrender. Almost immediately, Deputy Kent Kearney—nervous and jumpy—opens fire. Then the fight becomes general. One of Lee’s shots just misses Garrett’s head. Kearney is hit in the shoulder and groin, and he falls off the roof. Another deputy jumps down and is pinned by gunfire. Lee and Gililland pepper the water tank with bullets, soaking the lawman crouching behind it. Reportedly, Lee is laughing the whole time.

The shooting stops. Garrett orders the suspects to surrender; they refuse. In fact, Lee says, “Pat, don’t you think you’ve got the worst of this?” Garrett replies, “Don’t you think I know it?”

The two sides make a deal—Garrett and company will be allowed to leave and get help for Kearney, who lies wounded on the ground. The lawmen depart, later sending a railroad crew to get their injured comrade. It’s the most embarrassing moment in Pat Garrett’s law enforcement career.

Murder on the White Sands

The Fountains went missing in February 1896, during a trip from Lincoln to their home in Mesilla. Col. Albert J. Fountain was carrying documents concerning cattle rustling in southern New Mexico, which prominently accused Oliver Lee of playing a role. His eight-year-old son Henry accompanied him.

The bodies of the colonel and his son were never found, but searchers did find their buckboard, cartridge casings and pools of blood on the White Sands of New Mexico.

When Pat Garrett and his posse finally tracked down Lee and his accomplice James Gililland, the lawmen hadn’t planned on the killers getting the best of them.

After the gunfight, Lee and Gililland hightailed it out of Wildy Well. They allegedly hid out at the ranch of writer Eugene Manlove Rhodes. The pair finally surrendered to authorities (not Garrett) in March 1899.

They, along with Bill McNew, were tried in Hillsboro two years later for killing Henry. Their defense attorney was prominent politician and lawyer (and Fountain enemy) Albert Fall. Both were acquitted. Nobody was tried for the murder of Col. Fountain.

To this day, the disappearance of the Fountains remains one of the great mysteries of the Old West.

Aftermath: Odds & Ends

Mary Madison cared for Deputy Kent Kearney, removing the bullet from his groin. Later that afternoon, the section crew moved him
to Alamogordo for additional medical help. He died the next day.

Murder suspect Oliver Lee continued to be an important New Mexico rancher and later became a state legislator. Lee died in 1941. One of his ranches became a state park, bearing his name. Many historians—including researcher Corey Recko—believe that he and his cohorts killed the Fountains and got away with it.

Jim Gililland bought his own ranch in 1902 and lived a quiet life until his death in 1946. In 1927, he confessed that he’d helped Lee and Bill McNew kill the Fountains and bury their bodies in the White Sands area. He even identified the burial spot—but nothing was ever found there. Lee and McNew denied their pal’s claims.

Pat Garrett did not seek reelection as Doña Ana County sheriff. He shuffled from job to job throughout the next several years. He was gunned down on a lonely New Mexico road in late February 1908. Albert Fall again used his wiles in defending Garrett’s suspected killer, Wayne Brazel, by claiming self-defense. The verdict: not guilty. Some believed then—and now—that Lee was involved in a conspiracy to kill Garrett.

Recommended: Murder on the White Sands by Corey Recko, published by University of North Texas Press.

What do you think?

Bob Boze Bell

In 1999, Bob Boze Bell and partners bought True West magazine (published since 1953) and moved the editorial offices to Cave Creek, Arizona. Bell has published and illustrated books on Billy the Kid, Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday, as well as Classic Gunfights, an Old West gunfight book series. His latest books are The 66 Kid and True West Moments.