Borderland Mystery Review of James D. Crownover's If These Walls Could Talk.

mystery novel If These Walls Could Talk true west magazine
If These Walls Could Talk by James D. Crownover (Five Star, $25.95)

If These Walls Could Talk by James D. Crownover is a complex fictional story with a plethora of characters set in southern New Mexico and Arizona in the late 1880s.

The hero, young Dempsy Nealy, discovers a series of his family’s secrets—including murder—when he and fellow cowhand Saint Cooper are sequestered to an abandoned ranch house during the 1918 flu epidemic. They spend the winter months reading old newspapers tacked to the walls only to uncover more questions than answers.

After winter, the two friends seek answers to the unsolved mysteries and run into cattle thieves, Pancho Villa’s army, “El Tigre,” and a gang of miscreants.

—Melody Groves, author of Colton Brothers Saga and She Was Sheriff

What do you think?