Is This Doc Holliday? After having only two adult photographs of the gunfighting dentist, has another been found?

New Doc Holliday Photo
Do you believe this is a photograph of the dentist most known for his participation in the 1881 Gunfight Behind the O.K. Corral in Tombstone, Arizona? Found near St. Louis, Missouri, by professional photographer Donald J. McKenna, the albumen print, measuring 3 7⁄8 inches by 5½ inches, is mounted on a plain, unmarked, cream-colored card. No provenance links the photo directly to the dentist, but detailed anatomical comparison suggests a match between the known image (the 1872 photo) and the unauthenticated one.
– Courtesy Donald J. McKenna –

A man in his middle 30s sits in a pushchair, its wheels and his lap covered by a blanket. He is emaciated. His neck is wrapped to conceal infected lymph nodes. His hands are limp, and his eyes have the thousand-yard stare characteristic of late-stage tuberculosis.

Nothing in or about the photo itself suggests a date later than the mid-1880s. It was part of a large collection of 19th-century photographs purchased at an estate sale held at an elegant old home in Webster Groves, a suburb of St. Louis, Missouri.

Compare this image to one of young dentist John Henry Holliday, taken at the age of 20 for his 1872 graduation from the Pennsylvania College of Dental Surgery—one of two adult photos of him (the other is a signed photo of him taken in Prescott, Arizona, in 1879).

In both photos, notice the man’s sharply arched brows, the deep-set eyes, the jug ears. The noses are both straight, with a slight upward tilt at the tip. The cheekbones are wide and slightly depressed, relative to the lower jaws. The lengths of the jawlines are similar, as are the broad chins and the overall shapes of the faces. Those characteristics don’t change much with age and are used by modern facial recognition software to indicate a match between photos.

The older man’s mustache is more filled out, but not heavy. His hairline is equally high above a broad forehead, combed back instead of parted. Could this newfound photo be of Doc Holliday?

The honest answer is, we’ll never know, but this is how we would expect Holliday to look 15 years after his graduation from dental school and shortly before his death from tuberculosis.

Whether this is Holliday himself or some other poor soul dying of tuberculosis in the 1880s, perhaps this is how Holliday should be remembered: frail, but dignified; calm in the face of his death.

One last detail. Holliday was always careful about his clothing. The older man is wearing a soft cotton shirt, with sleeves that have been ironed to a knife-edge crease.

Author of acclaimed novels Doc (Random House, 2011) and Epitaph (Ecco/HarperCollins, 2015), Mary Doria Russell holds a Ph.D. in biological anthropology; she taught head and neck anatomy at the Case Western Reserve University School of Dental Medicine.

 

Doc Holliday 1872
John Henry “Doc” Holliday’s 1872 graduation photo is one of two adult photos of the gunfighting dentist authenticated by the Holliday family.
– Courtesy Robert G. McCubbin Collection –

What do you think?