Vengeance for a Marshal

Dave Mather

Cowboys who killed a New Mexico lawman paid a price.

On January 22, 1880, drunk cowboys were causing trouble in a Las Vegas, New Mexico saloon. Marshal Joe Carson and Deputy “Mysterious” Dave Mather (photo) intervened. The rowdies killed Carson, but Mather returned fire, leaving one cowboy dead and two hurt. Two of the men managed to escape; they were captured two weeks later. A mob lynched them in Las Vegas—while Joe Carson’s widow shot bullets into their bodies.

Related Posts

  • Harvey Whitehill

    Silver City, New Mexico Marshal, Harvey Whitehill was working to solve a train robbery at…

  • vengeancemoon

    Harried from his Virginia home by a murder he didn’t commit, Mountain Man Matt Slaughter…

  • Milton Duffield was a seasoned gunman, claiming his first victim in 1854.  That reputation must…