Who had the fastest draw: John Wesley Hardin, Wild Bill Hickok or Doc Holliday?
John H. Harper
Leeds, Yorkshire, England

That’s a tough one—especially since they never shot it out with one another. Holliday wasn’t really a gunfighter. Hickok was good with a gun. Hardin was deadly.

The latter two reportedly had a little run-in at Abilene, Kansas, in 1871. Hickok, who was the town marshal, ordered young Wes to turn over his guns. Hardin presented them, butts forward—and then spun them around into a firing position. Obviously, he didn’t pull the trigger. The only account we have of the incident comes from Hardin’s autobiography, which is not the most accurate source in the world.

So who was fastest? It’s good debate fodder. But as those guys used to say, “Speed is fine, but accuracy is final.”

Related Articles

  • john-wesley-hardin-in-1871-blog

    That’s a legend spread by Hardin in his 1896 autobiography. The event supposedly happened in…

  • gip hardin death certificate true west magazine

    John Wesley Hardin’s youngest brother Gip—like most of the men in the family—led a strange…

  • What is your opinion of John Wesley Hardin? Bill Calloway Wilmington, Delaware I view John…