I saw comparison photos of Etta Place and Ann Bassett, and they look identical to me. Was Ann Etta?

 

I saw comparison photos of Etta Place and Ann Bassett, and they look identical to me. Was Ann Etta?

Mike King
Middletown, New Jersey

You are not the first person to raise that theory. Doris Karren Burton published a booklet in 1992, Queen Ann Bassett Alias Etta Place, arguing that the Brown’s Park pioneer was the Sundance Kid’s girlfriend known to us as Etta Place.

Wild Bunch historian Daniel Buck dismisses her theory. A physical resemblance is not enough (a lot of look-alikes can be found in this world). Although Bassett was absent from Brown’s Park, Colorado, while the couple was on the South American ranch with Butch Cassidy, evidence suggests she went to Texas. Plus, Bassett never claimed to be Place.

No one knows for certain what happened to Place. She flat out vanished. When I look at that photo of her with the Sundance Kid in New York City, I’m reminded of another photo that turned out to be a major mistake, the Fort Worth Five photo with Cassidy, the Sundance Kid, Will Carver, Ben Kilpatrick and Harvey Logan (see the photo on
p. 144). The last thing a smart outlaw should do is have his photo taken.

Related Posts

  • ann bassett colorados cattle queen true west magazine

    She fought outlaws, gunmen and rustlers...and won.

  • charlie bassett true west

    Charlie Bassett has been overshadowed by his friends Bat Masterson and Wyatt Earp.  But he…

  • The enigmatic Etta, (Ethel) Place is one of the Old West’s most enthralling mysteries. We…