What can you tell me about William T. Phillips, who claimed to be Butch Cassidy in the early 1920s?

Jim Freed

Dennison, Ohio

Butch Cassidy expert Dan Buck says, “The major book on William T. Phillips is, of course, Larry Pointer’s In Search of Butch Cassidy. That’s the book that tattooed Phillips onto Butch’s behind, so to speak.

“Phillips’ own narrative, The Bandit Invincible, has more than a few problems. He claims Parker wasn’t Butch’s real name. He has Butch and Sundance’s ranch in the wrong part of Argentina. He says he held up trains in Bolivia that weren’t built yet when Butch was down there. The November 1908 shoot-out in Bolivia he claims he escaped from before getting married in Michigan occurred several months after his May 1908 marriage in Michigan.”

For history on the real Butch, Buck recommends Richard Patterson’s Butch Cassidy: A Biography and Anne Meadows’ Digging Up Butch and Sundance, which debunk the Phillips myth in greater detail.

Related Articles

  • The Outlaw Trail book cover

    Charles Kelly was a Salt Lake City printer when he got to know cowboy artist…

  • butch-blog

    Butch Cassidy was tired of the outlaw trail.  So in 1899, he tried to cut…

  • butch cassidy castle true west

    What’s the tie between a legendary Scottish castle and an Old West outlaw? Doune Castle,…