The Internet auction service, eBay, is a hothouse of Butch and Sundance photographs. Images turn up on eBay with little more provenance than “You be the judge” or “I’ve been told it looks like Butch.” If the unidentified man wears a bowler hat, so much the better. One recent offering claimed to depict a 30-something Butch in 1879, when he was but 13. Long before the Internet, outlaw historians were publishing dubious photos of Butch and Sundance, because there are so few legitimate

December 2014
In This Issue:
More In This Issue
- A Dangerous Eggnog
- William S. Hart Sr.
- Pawnee Power
- The Marvels of Marlin’s Model ’89
- The Toughest Man West of the Pecos
- The Great McGinty
- Branded But Unbroken
- Fires Can’t Blacken Colorado Springs
- Criminal Intentions
- Ragtown to Riches
- December Events 2014
- The Little Big Man Hoax?
- Jim Rodgers
- What can you tell me about Virgil Earp’s time in Colton, California?
- What is Taos Lightning?
- Did cowboys actually use saddlebags?
- What was the preferred mode of Old West travel—stagecoach or train?
- Was abolitionist John Brown a good guy or bad guy?
- Dirt Floor Paradise
- 1776: A Continental Revolution
- Was Bat Masterson as handy with his fists as he was with a gun?
- A Horror Maestro Goes West
- Drum Beat
- Paul Cool: History Sleuth on the Trail of the Truth
- Rough Drafts 12/14
- Grand Adventures of an Early American Explorer
- A Tale of Vengeance and Redemption
- Pueblo Rights in the Land of Enchantment
- Living and Dying as Outlaw Brothers