Did Cole Younger have any children? I ask because a doctor in town comes into my barbershop and claims to be his great-grandson.

Phil Thomas
Downers Grove, Illinois

The genealogy listed in Marley Brant’s book on the Youngers notes that Cole, Jim, Bob and John sired no children. If the doctor’s lineage traces back to one of the other Younger siblings (Henry and Bersheba Younger had nine other children), Cole would not be the doctor’s great-grandfather, but rather his great-granduncle.

One persistent myth, denied by Cole until his dying day, is that he fathered a child with Belle Starr. Cole met Starr when she was married to Jim Reed and was already four months pregnant. Reed and Cole were friends and had been fellow guerrilla fighters during the Civil War. Upon learning Starr had a teenage crush on him, Cole avoided her. Starr named her daughter Pearl and often claimed Cole was the father. Probably wishful thinking. Ironically, after Reed was killed, Starr married Cole’s uncle, Bruce Younger.

Marshall Trimble
is Arizona’s official historian. His books include

The Arizona Trilogy

and Law of the Gun.

If you have a question, write: Ask the Marshall,

PO Box 8008, Cave Creek, AZ 85327.

Related Articles

  • cole younger true west

    If I had to choose a favorite outlaw, without hesitation I’d say, “Cole Younger.” Besides…

  • Doctor George Goodfellow true west

    Dr. George Goodfellow is best known as the physician who treated Morgan and Virgil Earp…

  • They called the Arizona town Two Guns—supposedly after one of the early settlers, a crotchety…