Was Tom Horn really guilty of the murder for which he was hanged?
Scott Duvall
Appleton, Minnesota
Tom Horn was hanged in Cheyenne, Wyoming, on November 20, 1903, for the ambush killing of 14-year-old Willie Nickell. The debate on his guilt or innocence is still going on.
Dean F. Krakel, author of The Saga of Tom Horn, believed Horn did shoot Nickell in a case of mistaken identity. In Tom Horn: Blood on the Moon, Chip Carlson argued that Horn most likely didn’t kill the boy.
Horn

June 2014
In This Issue:
More In This Issue
- Bad Hand Mackenzie
- The Northern Plains to the Pacific Northwest
- Dead Is Better
- The Gang Slayer
- Treasures of the Old West
- A Man to Match the Land
- Did Doc Holliday Hunt Down Old Man Clanton?
- Custer Captured
- Beware of the Candied Cherries
- Mark Lee Gardner
- Happy 100th Birthday, Allan Houser
- A Wild Western Zine
- The Myths of a Border Warrior
- Life and Death of a Ranger
- Roaring Twenties Cowboy Noir
- An Open Wound
- Territorial Greed: Sins and Sinners of the Santa Fe Ring Revealed
- In the Tombstone Territory TV series, why are the characters given fake names when the show was based on real events?
- How did cowboys brush their teeth?
- When did billiards become popular in the Old West?
- Did Old West-style gunfights take place after 1910?
- Was Tom Horn really guilty of the murder for which he was hanged?
- The Monogram Cowboy Collection, Volume 7
- The “Shoot Today, Kill Tomorrow” Gun
- Where Cody Lives
- Saving Luke Short’s Hotel
- Mountain Man Rediscovered
- Rough Drafts 6/14
- Robert J. Conley
- June 2014 Events