Jim Anderson was the brother of Confederate guerrilla leader “Bloody Bill” Anderson. After the Civil War, Jim took up with the James-Younger Gang. In April 1866, Anderson shot Ike Flannery in the back of the head and robbed his body.
That didn’t set well with George Shepherd (photo), another associate of Jesse James—and Flannery’s uncle. It took him a year to settle the score, but when he did, Shepherd did it in style. In May 1867, he cut Anderson’s throat—on the grounds of the

True West March/April 2025
In This Issue:
Western Books & Movies
More In This Issue
- Truth Be Known
- What Has Taught Me: Deb Goodrich
- Earp, Cowboy Songs & Prairie Hygiene
- Trails of the Old West
- The Frontier Characters of South Dakota
- The Bowie Knife
- The Kindled Flame 1835
- King of the Scatterguns
- Selling the Mythic West and the Real West
- A Gut Punch Turns into a Miracle Reprieve
- The Beginnings of the Bird Cage
- Frontier Colossus