As the historical interpreter for the Buckhorn Saloon & Museum in San Antonio, I portray Wild Bill Hickok for the visitors. Were his 1851 Navy Colts silver plated?

Col. T. B. Reinhardt

Canyon Lake, Texas


Hickok biographer Joseph G. Rosa says, “Circa 1866, Hickok replaced his standard Navies, that is with walnut stocks, for a pair of plain (not engraved) 1851 Navies that were blued and case hardened, as per normal, but had ivory grips. The mountings—that is the trigger guard and back straps—were brass silver plated, usually described as ‘silver mounted’ in the press or trade advertisements.”

Hickok was photographed carrying both pistols, butts forward, as per the custom of the time, at Fort Harker, Kansas, in September 1867 and in Mendota, Illinois, in March 1869. The pistols look worn or shiny due to wear, but they certainly were not silver plated.

Related Articles

  • In this first biography of Agnes Lake, the woman finally steps out of the shadows…

  • In the November 2016 issue of True West, Bob Boze Bell’s picture shows “Wild Bill”…

  • What pistol did Wild Bill Hickok favor? David Edelen Millbrook, Alabama Hickok’s weapon of choice…