Charles Ray liked to hang out with bad guys. Going by the name Pony Diehl (or Deal), he first gained notice as a member of the John Kinney and Jesse Evans Gangs. He later rode for “The House,” the Murphy-Dolan faction, during the Lincoln County War.
Then Diehl headed west—to Tombstone (photo), where he became a Cowboy. He was accused in the shooting of Virgil Earp, but never tried. Later in 1882, he claimed to have killed “Johnny Behind the Deuce” O’Rourke—again, not prove

True West March/April 2025
In This Issue:
Western Books & Movies
More In This Issue
- Truth Be Known
- What Has Taught Me: Deb Goodrich
- Earp, Cowboy Songs & Prairie Hygiene
- Trails of the Old West
- The Frontier Characters of South Dakota
- The Bowie Knife
- The Kindled Flame 1835
- King of the Scatterguns
- Selling the Mythic West and the Real West
- A Gut Punch Turns into a Miracle Reprieve
- The Beginnings of the Bird Cage
- Frontier Colossus