Why are Old West figures portrayed in such black-and-white terms—either they’re all good or all bad?
W.W. Reed
Chandler, Arizona
Hollywood has given us a sterilized and romanticized image of the real West because audiences want their history to be uncomplicated, to be easy to take in and to take sides.
We all do it, including me. I’d rather see Sam Elliott take on the bad guys than some foul-smelling scoundrel with rotten teeth. A movie has only an hour and a half to present a crisis a

June 2017
In This Issue:
Western Books & Movies
More In This Issue
- Bust Cream, Anyone?
- Life and Death on the Fur Trade Frontier
- Paranoia Takes Jim Murhpy
- The Cheapskate of All Time
- The Horseless Carriage Was Seriously Underestimated
- Shopping from Home in 1897 with Sears Roebuck
- Outselling the Best Sellers–Sears Roebuck
- Mattie Summerhayes: An Army Bride from New England Follows the Guidon
- The Osage, Oil and the FBI
- While on a Cattle Drive, Did Cowboys Wear Their Handguns or Store Them?
- A Western Shootist is Born
- The Secret Artillery
- Good for a Laugh… and a Shiver
- The Western War Between the States
- She Was the Best Man of the Party
- A Preacher Comes to Helldorado: Part III
- Western Wisdom Worth Remembering
- What Happened to the Guns Used in the Gunfight Behind the O.K. Corral?
- You Tell ‘Em Girl
- Johnny Lingo: Arbuckles’, Bean Masters & Boiled Strawberries
- A Preacher Comes to Helldorado: Part II
- Rosebud Gets No Respect
- Mapping Our Way
- A Preacher Comes to Helldorado: Part I
Departments
- What History Has Taught Me: Howard Kazanjian
- Why Are Old West Figures Portrayed in Such Black-and-White Terms—Either They’re All Good or All Bad?
- On Walker, Texas Ranger, Chuck Norris Had a Recurring Role, Told via Flashbacks, as 19th Century Texas Ranger Hayes Cooper. Did Such a Man Exist?
- Dinner in Deadwood with Calamity Jane
- The Battle of Turkey Creek Canyon
- Western Events for June 2017
- Did Any Indian Tribes Break Treaties the Way the U.S. Government Did?
- Colt’s Paterson—the Foaling of a Legend
- A Woman’s Work is Never Done
- Did Augustine Chacon Kill 52 Men?