Was “Doc” a prolific killer?
Jim McCall
Chico, California
No. John Henry “Doc” Holliday’s only confirmed kill was Tom McLaury at the O.K. Corral gunfight in Tombstone, Arizona Territory, on October 26, 1881. He possibly killed Mike Gordon in Las Vegas, New Mexico Territory, in 1879, but many bullets were flying that night; his shot may not have been the fatal one.
Holliday did get into a fair amount of trouble. In 1873, he reportedly shot at black youngsters in his uncle’s swimmi

True West October 2018
In This Issue:
Features
Western Books & Movies
More In This Issue
- Lieutenant Charles Gatewood and the Johnson County War
- A Man Alone?
- The Lawman on the Lam
- Brother Vs. Brother
- An Act of Dignity and Strength
- Comstock Inferno
- Virginia City, Montana
- Boot Camp or Basic Training
- Peaches or Tso-ay
- Don’t Mess with the Rangers
- One More Killing
- An Apache Named Fun
- History and the Myth
- The Price of Leadership
- Bits and Pieces to Chew On
- Any Bullet Will Do
Departments
- What History Has Taught Me: Red Steagall
- From Slavery to Cattle King
- What did American Indians Smoke in their Peace Pipes?
- Was “Doc” a Prolific Killer?
- Horrors of Stage Station Grub
- Western Events for October 2018
- Ike Bites the Dust
- Were U.S. Army Troops Allowed to Carry their own Weapons?
- A Real Western Colt in the Reel West
- How were Cattle Cared for when they were Shipped to Slaughterhouses?
- Lone Ranger’s Iconic Saddle
- Why Were Only the Front Hooves of Mules Shod?
- Return to Fort Apache
- The Father of Montana
- What was the Name of Frank Stilwell’s Saloon in Charleston?